Chinese radicals - a fact sheet
When we teach or learn Chinese characters, the concept of radicals will for sure pop up. There are many books, posters and flash cards dedicated to radicals. The format usually is, first introduce a radical (sometimes accompanied with a picture), then explain the meaning of this radical, and finally teach a cluster of Chinese characters having this radical. The underlining belief is that if students learn a radical, consequently they will be able to understand many Chinese characters related to this radical. And this, my dear reader, is the biggest misconception about Chinese radicals.
In this article, I will explain what Chinese radicals are, why it is wrong to believe that students can learn Chinese characters through radicals. Later, we will give some facts about radicals, followed by some common ones at the end.
What are Chinese radicals?
The concept of radicals comes from describing the picto-phonetic characters.
According the method of creation, Chinese characters are divided into four groups: pictographic characters (象形字), indicative characters (指示字), associative characters (会意字), and picto-phonetic characters (形声字). The biggest group is the picto-phonetic characters, containing more characters than the other three combined.
When describing a picto-phonetic character, we usually divide it into two halves, one half as the meaning radical (形旁), and the other half the phonetic radical (声旁). For example “妈”. 女 is the meaning radicals, indicating that 妈 is a female, and 马 is the phonetic radicals, indicating that the sound of 妈 is “ma”. It is pretty neat in this case. However, as we will explain, this is not a general rule.
The misconception about Chinese radicals
Since radicals provide clues for the characters, hence, as the misconception goes, that mastering radicals helps understand the meanings of Chinese characters.
In this approach, students learn radicals first, characters later. However, if we take a close look, we will find it is wrong.
To use our earlier example, if students learn that 女 is “woman, female”, a meaning radical, and 马 is “horse”, a phonetic radical, then they are presented with a new character 妈, the most logical conclusion must be that 妈 means “a female horse”.
女 (meaning radicals) + 马 (phonetic radicals) = 妈 (female horse?)
This is obviously wrong. The reason is that we are trying to explain something which is not self explanatory. The actual learning direction is that students learn a number of Chinese characters, consequently they will be able to break them down and pick out some common radicals.
Students learn the meanings of the character 妈 as “mother”, and then learn the composition of this character.
妈 (mother) = 女 (meaning radicals) + 马 (phonetic radicals)
The fact sheet
When we discuss Chinese radicals, the rule of thumb is that there is no rule of thumb.
Chinese radicals are versatile and flexible. If someone claims that all meaning radicals indicate meanings, she will be disappointed when they don't. Or if someone claims that all phonetic radicals give clues to the sounds of characters, she will be disappointed when they bear no relationship at all.
The best we can do to understand Chinese radicals is through a number of facts about them.
Some radicals can be a meaning radical in one Chinese character, and a phonetic radical in another. For example:
Meaning radicals don’t always indicate the meanings. For example: “亻” does not indicate “a person” in these characters, 什, 仅, 仿, 值.
There are some meaning radicals which indicate the same meaning but with different looks. For example:
Radicals occupy different positions in different characters. Below is a table listing where a phonetic radical can appear. The same goes with meaning radicals.
When radicals appear at different positions, the length of strokes sometimes change. For example: when 女 is on the left, the horizontal stroke is shortened, such as 好, when at bottom, the same stroke is at its full length, such as 要. When 土 is on the left, the second horizontal stroke goes up, such as 地, when at the bottom, at its full length, such as 坐.
There are some relationship between the sound of a Character and its phonetic radical, but not enough to decide how to read that character.
In this table, only 洋 takes the sound of its phonetic radical 羊. 邻 takes only the initial of 令. And 汉 bears no relationship with 又.
Some phonetic radicals look almost the same, but their pronunciations are very different.
Conclusion on Chinese radicals
Chinese radicals are a complex phenomenon, and they do not directly help students understand Chinese characters, let alone Chinese texts. Spending too much time on radicals steers students away from the real goal, building up the ability in reading and writing Chinese texts.
This is the reason that Chinese Reading and Writing series does not teach Chinese radicals. Fortunately, This article can be used as a supplementary reading to the series.
Common Meaning Radicals
月(left position, body): 胖、服、肚
月(right position, time): 期、朝
阝(left position, fence): 阳、院、除
阝(right position, city): 那、都、邮
Common Phonetic Radicals
© 2019 MSL Master, Hong Kong. All Rights Reserved